Kael stared at Dubium, intrigued.

  “The Velasquez Limit?”

  The man had just finished setting up the chessboard. He leaned forward and poured the tea slowly, as if each gesture belonged to a greater balance.

  Kael thanked him without taking his eyes off him.

  Dubium remained silent for a moment, then finally spoke:

  “It is… a boundary.

  A threshold.

  It was not designed to control the cycle…

  but to allow one to escape it.”

  Kael frowned slightly.

  “A way out of the ouroboros,” Dubium added more softly.

  “The Velasquez Limit rests on a simple idea… though a disturbing one.

  If one truly understands the cause—before the consequence erupts—

  then the cycle can be broken.”

  Kael looked up.

  “But how could you prevent a consequence…

  if the cause is already there?”

  He picked up a white piece and slid it across the board.

  An aggressive, straightforward opening. A statement as much as a move.

  Dubium studied the board. He took a black piece and slowly turned it between his fingers.

  “That is correct.

  Theoretically… it is impossible.”

  He raised his eyes to Kael.

  “Unless something…

  interrupts time.

  Or alters the interval between the cause and effects.”

  He set the piece down. A cautious, defensive move—but prepared.

  Then he held Kael’s gaze for a long moment.

  Silence settled between them, dense, as if even the words hesitated to cross the threshold.

  Kael’s eyes widened.

  “…And that would create a loop…

  A loop that returns to the original cause…

  Each time it is about to generate a consequence…”

  His hands were trembling.

  He leaned back slightly on the couch, breath short.

  I am… inside the ouroboros of causality, he thought faintly

  His eyes wavered. He swallowed.

  Yet despite the confusion, despite the vertigo overtaking him, he reached out, seized a piece, and moved it.

  A controlled move. Deliberate.

  A reflex stronger than panic.

  “Why?” he whispered.

  “Why am I here?”

  Dubium did not answer immediately.

  He did not play.

  He simply looked at him.

  Once again, Kael realized he was incapable of describing the color of his eyes.

  As if their shade shifted from moment to moment—

  or had never truly existed.

  Dubium finally spoke, his voice deep yet composed:

  “That is a good question.

  But it is for you to answer, young man.”

  He paused, then added:

  “Why are you here?”

  And he played.

  A precise answer. Calm. Almost imperceptible on the board.

  Yet it resonated like an echo in Kael’s mind.

  Kael did not reply.

  He was thinking.

  I am inside the Trial… he thought.

  But I still haven’t seen the shadow of the choice I’m supposed to make.

  He made his move, fingers steady even as his thoughts faltered.

  Then he continued inwardly:

  This entire ouroboros… it has to be connected to that.

  There is a cause I do not know. And I must identify it.

  A piece clicked against the board. Dubium had moved.

  Did you know this story is from Royal Road? Read the official version for free and support the author.

  Kael kept thinking, his gaze still locked on the chessboard:

  It’s tied to my flaw. That disturbance I feel… without being able to name it.

  But I know… I know my mother is connected to it.

  He played again. A precise move. Almost mechanical.

  That’s why I’m here. But where is the choice?

  I don’t see it.

  A bitter smirk crossed his face.

  They didn’t lie to me.

  It’s terribly insidious.

  Dubium took his time before counterattacking.

  Kael remained lost in thought.

  I need to start over from the beginning.

  He saw himself again in the carriage.

  The coachman.

  The words he had spoken without hesitation.

  Remanence is when you choose to accept what you are. Your flaws, your doubts, everything that hurts. You take them, you understand them, and you make them useful.

  Kael rubbed his forehead, as if trying to calm the chaos forming inside it.

  He made his move almost by reflex.

  And the thought persisted, relentless:

  Dissonance is the opposite. It’s when you refuse what you are.

  When you want to break it—tear it out.

  Not deny it. Not flee from it.

  Twist it. Reshape it into something new.

  A rupture… or a rebirth, depending on how you live it.

  He briefly closed his eyes.

  Both suffer.

  Both change.

  For the first time, Dubium hesitated.

  A suspended moment.

  Then he played.

  Kael felt the shift. He lifted his eyes to the board.

  He pushed his thoughts aside for a moment and gathered himself.

  This was the closest game he had ever played.

  And this time, it was no longer just about chess.

  A wave of dizziness swept over him.

  Both suffer. Both change.

  The sentence echoed in his mind.

  Again. And again.

  It refused to leave him.

  He made his move, almost reluctantly, as if the simple gesture was no longer enough to contain what was rising within him.

  Remanence suffers because it accepts.

  Dissonance suffers because it rejects.

  A dull pressure tightened around his chest.

  An obvious truth—long suppressed—was trying to surface.

  And yet… both exist.

  Because they suffer, they are real.

  His mind returned to what Dubium had said earlier.

  “To suffer is to exist.”

  And now, he truly understood.

  Suffering was not a symptom.

  It was a marker.

  Proof that something was there—alive, in transformation.

  So if both paths suffer… then both exist.

  He inhaled slowly.

  But… if they both exist, and both make me suffer…

  He slowly lifted his eyes toward the chessboard, without truly seeing the pieces.

  … is there a third choice?

  The silence thickened around him.

  Everything seemed suspended—even time itself.

  Not an answer.

  A question.

  But a new one.

  A crack in the ouroboros.

  Dubium played a masterful move.

  A sharp, decisive motion—almost silent—yet one that forced Kael to reconsider his entire strategy.

  A perfect trap.

  Kael felt the pressure rising.

  He was cornered.

  And yet, he played.

  Without forcing it. Without resisting.

  A natural move. As if the answer were coming from somewhere deeper than himself.

  He didn’t look up. He was thinking.

  That’s it…

  This is the very foundation of the Trial.

  An ouroboros leading to two distinct consequences: Remanence and Dissonance.

  Two paths. Two ways to suffer. Two ways to exist.

  Those choices had always been presented to him as the only possible outcomes.

  Perfect opposites.

  A binary equilibrium.

  But no one had ever questioned that assumption.

  He frowned slightly.

  What if…

  What if someone refused to choose?

  Not to flee.

  Not to ignore.

  But to refuse the very framework of the choice.

  What if a third path existed?

  Not a negation of the first two… but something else.

  A thought began to take shape.

  Incomplete. Unstable.

  But real.

  What if the third choice… was to understand the loop without submitting to it.

  Neither to accept the suffering.

  Nor to twist it.

  But to pass through it.

  To listen to it.

  To absorb it without identifying with it.

  To become the witness of the loop… instead of one of its cogs.

  Kael felt his heart beating faster.

  He still didn’t know how to name this possibility.

  But he knew it existed.

  And that alone was enough to change the entire game.

  Dubium played.

  A lightning strike of a move.

  Unstoppable, at first glance.

  The kind of move that would make any player fold.

  But not Kael.

  Not this time.

  Not in this precise moment.

  He saw the trap.

  And slipped out of it with almost instinctive fluidity.

  An elegant counter. Defensive, yet sovereign.

  He breathed slowly, his thoughts aligning as the pieces moved.

  The cause of the Trial… is my inner fracture.

  And the consequences are clear: Remanence or Dissonance.

  He frowned.

  But then… if those two responses are consequences, like the two arms of a scale…

  What lies between them?

  He felt a strange tension rise within him.

  Not fear.

  A shift.

  And then he understood:

  The third choice is not a path. It is a position.

  Neither to accept the suffering.

  Nor to reject it.

  But to look at it directly—without absorbing it, without fleeing from it.

  A lucid gaze. Detached.

  Not cold. Not indifferent.

  Just… aware.

  Kael felt his heartbeat slow.

  It was neither resistance…

  Nor resignation.

  It was naked consciousness. Deep doubt. The suspension of judgment.

  And in that precise place, between the two binary answers, he glimpsed something else.

  A fragile point of equilibrium.

  A narrow space…

  But a real one.

  Active doubt.

  Not the kind that paralyzes.

  The kind that questions.

  That refuses frameworks.

  That observes without deciding too soon.

  What if that was the true role of the Velasquez Limit?

  Not to dictate a choice.

  But to suspend the cycle.

  To create a void.

  Just wide enough…

  For something new to be born.

  Dubium played another move.

  Cold. Calculated. Destabilizing.

  Kael answered immediately.

  Without faltering.

  His movements were swift—but precise.

  His eyes were trembling.

  So were his hands.

  But it wasn’t fear.

  It was exhilaration.

  I’m touching something… I can feel it.

  If I want to put this reasoning into practice…

  If I want to reach the Velasquez Limit…

  I have to understand the cause.

  The cause of my fracture.

  He inhaled deeply, without lifting his eyes.

  If I don’t…

  I’ll never be able to judge the consequences.

  I’ll keep enduring them.

  Reproducing them.

  Again and again.

  I’ll perpetuate the ouroboros.

  He moved his piece.

  A pure movement. Fluid.

  As if it had come from somewhere beyond him.

  Kael was no longer entirely there.

  Not in the room.

  Not in the loop.

  Not even in the game.

  He was elsewhere.

  Focused on a single idea:

  To understand.

  To see the cause. To confront it. To look it in the eyes.

  Dubium studied the board.

  Silence fell—thick, oppressive.

  He slowly moved a piece and set it down with care.

  Then, in a steady, calm voice—almost solemn:

  “Checkmate.”

  A heartbeat hung suspended.

  The game was over.